Helping parents nurture healthy babies

Breastfeeding-A Moral Imperative?

There are many reasons to breastfeed.  Mothers' milk provides nutrients and antibodies that help protect the baby.  And, breastfeeding can even help your body get back into shape and into it's routine.  But there are also many reasons not to breastfeed.  We've covered them before in this blog, but I'll name a few.  Perhaps you can't for medical reasons, or maybe you don't produce enough milk.  Maybe it's just not the best choice for your family's dynamic.  That's not a sin.  Some mothers find it stressful.  And stress isn't good for the baby or other family members.

U.S. health officials are trying to increase breast feeding rates for all good reasons.  But many groups and people are pressuring new moms through guilt.  They allege you're not being a good mother if you don't breastfeed, or that you're not giving your baby the best possible chance you can.  I even saw one article that said people were equating formula with giving babies the equivalent of MacDonalds! 

Too much pressure will backfire.  It already has actually.  Women who choose not to breastfeed are fed up.  There are now blogs galore dedicated to people who hate breastfeeding and are eager for support.  And there are plenty of people ready to support them.

Increasing breastfeeding rates is an admirable goal.  But the push to do so by radical lactivists has turned the debate into something volatile.  It has polarized mothers who, rather than fight each other, should support each other in their decisions.  Breastfeeding is not a 'moral imperative" as some would suggest.  Rather, it is a choice; one that is personal and should not invite judgement. 

Comments

Ameda Ultra

Thank you for the post, it\'s indeed one of the bests on subject, i am totally impressed. Nicole

Erin

I see that most of my comments have not been published, I assume because of their sarcastic nature. It is hard to not come across as sarcastic when responding to posts that are laced with words like "radical," "give me a break," and other such phrases along with the negative assumptions that the reason "lactivists" state facts about breastfeeding is solely to make other moms feel guilty. People share facts so that others can make informed choices, not to make people feel guilty. Guilt comes from within, when somebody feels badly about their decisions - which may be influenced by learning facts, but this is not solved by ignoring the facts or keeping silent about them. It is solved by mothers realizing that we do the best we can do given our situations and knowledge and abilities at the time, and therefore we should not feel guilt unless we really had malicious intent or were truly not trying to do the best we could.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.